 .   ,       
  

  

 


Skolkovo Business Review 
     .   ,       ,    ,    ?       ? Ƞ      ,    ,    ?

     ,             .

      ,        ,   .   ,     ,          ,   ,      ,      .





 ,  ,  

 .   ,       



 



      ,  Meta PlatformsInc.,     .



  .                     .



 ., .,  ., 2026

 . ΠԻ, 2026


* * *




:  ?


      ,          .         ,      ?    ,           ,             ?     ,           ?         ,  ,    ,       ,     , ,   -?             .

          .                  .           ?      ?              ?          ,            .

,     :   - ()   .      (  )        [1 -               ,    2015. URL: https://iems.skolkovo.ru/downloads/documents/SKOLKOVO_IEMS/Research_Reports/SKOLKOVO_IEMS_Research_2015-11-11_ru.pdf (https://iems.skolkovo.ru/downloads/documents/SKOLKOVO_IEMS/Research_Reports/SKOLKOVO_IEMS_Research_2015-11-11_ru.pdf).    . .,    .]        .                 -,  ,      .     ,             .

       -      :             ,      .                 ,         .

         .        , , ,      :           ,       ,  ,       ,      ,       .

    .    ,    ,       .     , ,        ,            .     ,       .  :            ,     .         :    ,      ,    [2 -   iPhone. ʠ             ,       -  ,        ,     .       Apple          .].     ,    .     :     ,     ,      ,     .  ,      ,    ,    .

    ? Π,    -,                 . Π,    ,         [3 -      .]. Π,      ,       ,        ,    .

             .     ,        .

1.           ,        ,     .                        (   ).      (    ),       .                    .

2.   ,   -,      .          :     , ,     ,          ,        .         ,     ,          ,      .

3.,       ,             .       ,      ,     .                      .     ,         ,      .            ,     ,      ,        .

     .  (#ch1)    .  ,            -,   -  ,  Amazon, Google, Alibaba, ,  ..,           Accord Hotels  Maersk     .    (#ch1)     ,       .

  (#litres_trial_promo)      .       ,   ,         ,  .   ,     . ,  ,            ,         .      : ,      ,         .           ,    .

   (#litres_trial_promo)       .      ,          .  ,  ,                ,    .  ,     ,   ,               ( ,           ).      , ,   ,       ,    -,        .

     ,        -.   , ,     ,            ?    ,       ,    ,  .   2008?[4 -  .   .  . 2013.]              ?  ,  ,    -    ,   ,  .       MBA  Executive MBA ,      ,       .       ,   :     ,  ,    . ,           ,    ,           .

    ?   ,     ,     .        ,     ,     ,      .

 -     ; ,          .          ,        .      :              ,    [5 -  , ,    GE   : 2016      GE Digital  -     , 2024      .].           ,   ,         .     ,             .         :     ,           .

         ;          .    -      :    ,     ,  -      ? ,            ,   .          , ,     .          ,     . ,    ,  ,       ,     -  .     , ,    ;          ,               . ʠ,      .     ,               .

                 .     ,      ,   ,      ,   ,       Nokia,     .   -   ,      ,     (    )    . ,         Maersk - 2020,      , ,  ;      .   ,    ,   ,                .     ,        .     ,    Nokia   ,   ,                .                 .

   ?   , , ,     ,           ,       ,    ,     -   .       ,   .        .          :     ,       - [6 - Robert J. System Effects: Complexity in Political and Social Life// Princeton University Press. 1997. 328p.].          ,     (        ).   ,           ,       ;                  ,        .

          .            , ,  .         ,     ,   ,     ,      ,         ,   MBA, EMBA     (             ).             ,     ,  ,  ,  ,  ,  .     :   ( ),   (),   ()  . ,  ,          .

     , ,       .      ,       [7 - ,      ,      ,     ,        (., 2012),    (., 2006),          (., 2018).     1990-           (  . . ).].     ,  SDA Bocconi,          .      ,   ,    ,       ,        .

 ,        ,      , ,         . ,       .    ,    , ,    ,        .                   , ,         .    ,    .         ,     ,  ,     ,  -          .          :    ,    [8 - Edward de Bono. New Thinking for the New Millennium. Beverly Hills, Ca: New Millennium Press, 1990.].  ,         ,          .            :                    .




 1.    -?



      ,       .         .         ,       ,         ,   .

 , [9 -  2020:       Google  Amazon// . 2017. URL: https://www.rbc.ru/finances/14/12/2017/5a3298649a79479b6882a13a (https://www.rbc.ru/finances/14/12/2017/5a3298649a79479b6882a13a).]

            ,               .   ?

    ,        ,       ?..

        ,         , ,  , .        ,      .

          (, , ),   ,      .   -.

        ,        .    ,     ,  ,     ,   . Ƞ         .

   ,            ,      .

                 .

   ,                ,   ,    : ,    ,     ,  .  -       ,     .

  :       -?       ?          ? Ƞ        ,      ?

       -,      .       ,            . , ,  ,                 .

        , -            ,       .

         -,       -  ,         ,         .

   ,              ,       .

 ,     ,      30   ,          .             -  .

      . -,       . -    ,    ,      ,  ,    .




 1.     


             [  ]    .     ,    ,   .          ,  1990  [10 - Rothshild M. Bionomics: Economy as Ecosystem. Henry Holt, 1992 (    1990.   : Bionomics. The Inevitability of Capitalism).].          ,       .

     .     ?????()  컠     .       ,     : ??????? ()  .

          XX.          :    ,   ,       ..   ,             .    ,      ;      ;        .

   ,       .   , ,            ,     .   ,              .    ,  ,      ,  ,   [11 -  ,       , ,   ..           ,      ,        ,       ,                  ( .   . 3- . .; .; : , 2023. .61).].               .      ,  ,  ,            -.

        19201930-       ,     [12 - ,                . ,  ,        ,        .                   .      ,             ,      .].

        ,          ,       ,     ,     , -     .

      [13 - Ackoff R. L. Creating the corporate future. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1981.]:

1.     .

2.         .

3.       .

 ,   ,    ,          - [14 - Jervis Rt. System Effects: Complexity in Political and Social Life. Princeton University Press, 1997. 328p.].  ,          .        ,        .      ,        . :              . : ,   ,         [15 - Laszlo ., Krippner S. Systems Theories: Their Origins, Foundations, and Development// Jordan J. S. (ed.) Systems Theories and A Priori Aspects of Perception. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science, 1998. Ch. 3. P.4774.].

          ,  1950-      .          ,             .      .                .               ?   ,    ,  -,      ..    ,    ,      ,      ..              ,    .

,          . ,              .      ,         . Ƞ, ,    :      .

              ,     [16 - ,     . ,             ,          ,    40%  .            ,         ,    .   ,        ,       ,                .           ,           (JervisR. System Effects: Complexity in Political and Social Life. Princeton University Press. 1997, 328 p.).     ,           ,       .            ,           ,  .].

 1984 Apple     Macintosh,      ,       ,     . Ƞ     : Apple   ,     ,        .      ,      .             Mac .   Apple      .       .

    , ,     ,    .        ,    .      [17 -      ,      1935,   , .]:      ,       .. ;                   .          -      . ,             ,                .   1950-          .       :   ,     ,             [18 - Boulding K. The Organizational Revolution. AStudy In the Ethics Of Economic Organization. Chicago: Quadrangel Books, 1953/1958.       : Boulding K. AReconsruciton of Economics. New York: Science Editions Inc., 1950.].

     ,      ,       .               . ,        [19 -  ,       1920-           ,          ,   ..            1950- .],[20 - Duncan O. D. From Social System to Ecosystem// Sociological Inquiry. 1961. 31. P.140149.],         ,    .           ,        .  ,     ,       .  1990           ,   ,       .

,  ,      , -             .   -   .

                  .  :         ,    -,    .  -  -     :       ,    ,         [21 -        ,    ,       ,           .],[22 - Moore J. Predators and Prey: A New Ecology of Competition// Harvard Business Review. 1993.].                : Apple, IBM, Tandy.        , , Ford, Merck, Walmart, Kmart.     ,     ,       :       .

    ,              ,   ,       .

     ,       -[23 - Moore J. Death of Competition: Leadership and Strategy in the Age of Business Ecosystems // Harpers Business. 1996.].   ,    ,      ,      .       ,     ,       .          ,    .

   30   ,  ,    .

        :

1)  ;

2)      ;

3)       ,         .

     Apple  iPhone  App Store.

  :       .

  : Apple  ,           .

 : Apple   iOS,    ,        .     :        (, Siri  ARKit),  Apple   ,    .    iPhone   ,   (Nokia, Motorola, Ericsson)     .

  ,      ,     .   -,     1990- ,    .    [24 - Moore J. Shared Purpose: A Thousand Business Ecosystems, aConnected Community, and the Future. Createspace, 2013.]           Arm Holdings.

     1995       ,      MIT Sloan Management Review[25 - Benjamin R., Wigand R. Electronic Markets and Virtual Value Chains on the Information Superhighway// MIT Sloan Management Review. 1995. Vol. 35, 2. P.6272.].    ,          ,  ,   .    ,               .

     ,  2002                .           .

         :           (.1).            , [26 -         ,    Cisco,    (networked organizations  transformed organizations)     . .: Nachira F. Towards a Network of Digital Business Ecosystems Fostering the Local Development. Bruxelles: European Comission, 2002; Martin L., Matlay H. Blanket approaches to promoting ICT in small firms: some lessons from the DTI ladder adoption model in the UK// Internet Research. 2001. 11 (5). P.399410.]:

   [ ];

   ;

      .













,               .             -.

   2002          :  Intel, Microsoft Cisco             -[28 - Nachira F. Towards a Network of Digital Business Ecosystems Fostering the Local Development. Bruxelles: European Comission, 2002.].         .     -      ,     ,       .       ,      .

 -, ,      ,   .          .      ,   ,  ,         .

     -. Ƞ        ,    ,   ,       .

       , ,         ,       Application Programming Interface[29 - API           .  , ,        App Store  Google Store.].

           .            [30 -  .,  .    .            . .: , 2020.]          . ,          ,     .         : ,    ,     .      ,    . ,   ,  ,    ,      ..       ,      ,        .  ,     ,   -.

     -     [31 -    network externalities.]:             .  , ,   .         ,   .  ,           ,  .            ,  :    ,          .

   ,     ,   .          ,   , ,    .          ,  ,   ,     .    -  .                .

 2013         -    ,   컠 pipleline[32 - Porter M. Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1985.] (.2). ,         ,       ,        ,       .


















 ,              ,   ,           .

                , ,      ,    ?

      ,     :

1.       ,           ,   .      ,      ,     .  ,          ,    ,    [35 - . : Croxson K., Frost J., Gambacorta L., Valletti T. Platform-based business models and financial inclusion// BIS Working Papers. 2022. 986.].  ,      (.  ),           ,      .

2.      ,     . , ,             . Ƞ       (   ).         ,     .  ,   ,     ,   , ,          .            ,      .       ,          .

3.,       :          .   ,    ,       ,         -.       ,     ,     .   ,    ,     ,      .

    . ,    ,  .            .   ,     ,   .      .       ,     ,    .

-   ,   -,      .     ,  ,       .

    ,        ,          .

 -   -;       .

    ,              ,     [36 -      . ,     Uber          .  Airbnb      ,    . ,        .].

    ,   ,        ,           .          ,        .      ,  ,            ,   ..

 ()      ,   ,        .          ,           .

 ()     (   ),           ,    ,       .




 

 2007       [37 - Niederle M., Roth A. E. Making Markets Thick: Designing Rules for Offers and Acceptances: preprint. 2007.]             .   ,     ,         .      .

          컠     .      ,   ,       .             ,        ,     .     ,      .          ,  . ,    ,       ,      :     ,   ()    ,  .         -         .      ,        ,  ,  ,      .        .      ,          [38 - Roth A. E. What have we learned from market design?// The Economic Journal. 2008. Vol.118, 527. P.285310.].

   .      .         ,        .    ,         ,   ,     , , ,   ,      .           ,        .          ,        .         B2B,         .

              .  ,    ,    .





  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=74458436)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes


Notes





1


              ,    2015. URL: https://iems.skolkovo.ru/downloads/documents/SKOLKOVO_IEMS/Research_Reports/SKOLKOVO_IEMS_Research_2015-11-11_ru.pdf (https://iems.skolkovo.ru/downloads/documents/SKOLKOVO_IEMS/Research_Reports/SKOLKOVO_IEMS_Research_2015-11-11_ru.pdf).    . .,    .




2


  iPhone. ʠ             ,       -  ,        ,     .       Apple          .




3


     .




4


 .   .  . 2013.




5


 , ,    GE   : 2016      GE Digital  -     , 2024      .




6


Robert J. System Effects: Complexity in Political and Social Life// Princeton University Press. 1997. 328p.




7


,      ,      ,     ,        (., 2012),    (., 2006),          (., 2018).     1990-           (  . . ).




8


Edward de Bono. New Thinking for the New Millennium. Beverly Hills, Ca: New Millennium Press, 1990.




9


 2020:       Google  Amazon// . 2017. URL: https://www.rbc.ru/finances/14/12/2017/5a3298649a79479b6882a13a (https://www.rbc.ru/finances/14/12/2017/5a3298649a79479b6882a13a).




10


Rothshild M. Bionomics: Economy as Ecosystem. Henry Holt, 1992 (    1990.   : Bionomics. The Inevitability of Capitalism).




11


 ,       , ,   ..           ,      ,        ,       ,                  ( .   . 3- . .; .; : , 2023. .61).




12


,                . ,  ,        ,        .                   .      ,             ,      .




13


Ackoff R. L. Creating the corporate future. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1981.




14


Jervis Rt. System Effects: Complexity in Political and Social Life. Princeton University Press, 1997. 328p.




15


Laszlo ., Krippner S. Systems Theories: Their Origins, Foundations, and Development// Jordan J. S. (ed.) Systems Theories and A Priori Aspects of Perception. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science, 1998. Ch. 3. P.4774.




16


,     . ,             ,          ,    40%  .            ,         ,    .   ,        ,       ,                .           ,           (JervisR. System Effects: Complexity in Political and Social Life. Princeton University Press. 1997, 328 p.).     ,           ,       .            ,           ,  .




17


     ,      1935,   , .




18


Boulding K. The Organizational Revolution. AStudy In the Ethics Of Economic Organization. Chicago: Quadrangel Books, 1953/1958.       : Boulding K. AReconsruciton of Economics. New York: Science Editions Inc., 1950.




19


 ,       1920-           ,          ,   ..            1950- .




20


Duncan O. D. From Social System to Ecosystem// Sociological Inquiry. 1961. 31. P.140149.




21


       ,    ,       ,           .




22


Moore J. Predators and Prey: A New Ecology of Competition// Harvard Business Review. 1993.




23


Moore J. Death of Competition: Leadership and Strategy in the Age of Business Ecosystems // Harpers Business. 1996.




24


Moore J. Shared Purpose: A Thousand Business Ecosystems, aConnected Community, and the Future. Createspace, 2013.




25


Benjamin R., Wigand R. Electronic Markets and Virtual Value Chains on the Information Superhighway// MIT Sloan Management Review. 1995. Vol. 35, 2. P.6272.




26


        ,    Cisco,    (networked organizations  transformed organizations)     . .: Nachira F. Towards a Network of Digital Business Ecosystems Fostering the Local Development. Bruxelles: European Comission, 2002; Martin L., Matlay H. Blanket approaches to promoting ICT in small firms: some lessons from the DTI ladder adoption model in the UK// Internet Research. 2001. 11 (5). P.399410.




27


Gawer A., Cusumano M. Platform Leadership How Intel, Microsoft, and Cisco Drive. Harvard Business Press, 2002.




28


Nachira F. Towards a Network of Digital Business Ecosystems Fostering the Local Development. Bruxelles: European Comission, 2002.




29


API           .  , ,        App Store  Google Store.




30


 .,  .    .            . .: , 2020.




31


   network externalities.




32


Porter M. Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1985.




33


Brousseau E., Penard T. The economics of digital business models: A framework for analyzing the economics of platforms// Review of Network Economics. 2007. Vol. 6 (2).




34


Choudary S. Why Business Models Fail: Pipes vs. Platforms// Wired. 2013. October. URL: https://www.wired.com/insights/2013/10/why-business-models-fail-pipes-vs-platforms/ (https://www.wired.com/insights/2013/10/why-business-models-fail-pipes-vs-platforms/).




35


. : Croxson K., Frost J., Gambacorta L., Valletti T. Platform-based business models and financial inclusion// BIS Working Papers. 2022. 986.




36


     . ,     Uber          .  Airbnb      ,    . ,        .




37


Niederle M., Roth A. E. Making Markets Thick: Designing Rules for Offers and Acceptances: preprint. 2007.




38


Roth A. E. What have we learned from market design?// The Economic Journal. 2008. Vol.118, 527. P.285310.


