  .       
  


               :  ( ,   . .)   ( ). ,             XVII-X .               , ,   .        .           ,  ,  ,  ,    .        ,          .

  , ,  ,   .    ,    ,         ,        .

  

  PDF A4    .





 

  .       



:

   .. 

   .. 



          (;   XVIII.).



  .., 2025

    , -,  , 2025


* * *




   


       , ,    .       , ,           . , ,         ,       ,       ,         .       ,  ,              .           ,           .              (    . , ..   .. )      ,        ,   ,      .  , ,               ,             1797.            ,      ,     ,   ,    .    ,    ( 2),       .        .      ,    ,               . ,       . ,        .


* * *

          XVIIIXX.  (    ,   ..)   ( ).       XVII  XVIII  ,      ,    -     .      (          XVIII. )     (  ),    ,    .        ,   . ,         ,        ,        ,              .         ,        .

      .  ,     ,     ,   ..[1 -         :  ()     ,    : .. 1431. . 1. 914. . 21 .]         ,  .           , , ,  ..   ,         : , , .         .   ,   ,       .    XIX.           ,  ,    19001910- .,          .            ,              .

  ,        XIX.,       (   컠 ,   ).  , ,   -           .      .         ,      ,      .  ,   ,     ,        . ,    .. , ,      ,        ,  -   蔻[2 -  ..      .  , 1908. . 1. . 1.      . .I.].                  II. ..   ,             . ,              .

,   .  -     -          .  ,           ,        .           cult.             XX.[3 -      .:  ..  :   .     . , 2015. . 1. . 2850.],          .       ,  , . ,              , , ,  ..              ,   ,   ,         .  ,  (             ),    ,    - .  ,              ,      (      ,           )          .             XVIII   XX.            :              ,      .  ,     ,   -      ,        :    ,   ,                 .

                        ,        .          (,   ).   -             .    .   ,    -     , , ,    XVIII. , -,     . -           (  -   XIX.),   , -,  ,  ,  .  , ,     ..          .                 .

   XVIIIXIX.,       , ,   ,            -,   - .                ,     .        ,          ,       ,       ?    ,           ,               ,     ,      ,     .

,             . , , ,                ,     . .  ,  ,          ,    ,           .      ;          ;          [4 - Meyer B. Mediation and Immediacy: Sensational Forms, Semiotic Ideologies, and the Question of the Medium // A Companion to the Anthropology of Religion / Ed. by J. Boddy and M. Lambek. Oxford, 2013. P. 315.].

           .    ,     ,     .          (, ,   ,          ),    .        /    (,         ),     . ,     (hyper-apparent): ,  ,          [5 - Ibid. P. 317320.].

, ,       ? ,    XIX.       ,    ,      ,      ,      .        ,        . , ,          ,      (),        .           , ,     -:          ,          .

         ໠                       .         :   ,     ,            :



         ,   ,  -   ,  ,        .   ,   ,   ,      -         ,     ,       ,     ,      [6 -  ..     .  , 1914. . 11.].


,  ,           ,   ,           .     /                  .       XVIXVII., ,   ,           .       ,  ,      [7 - .  : Clay E. The Theological Origins of the Christ-Faith (Khristovshchina) // Russian History / Histoire Russe. 1988. Vol. 15. N 1. P. 2142.].           ()  (,    ,   )               .

     ,  , .     ,     .      :          .          : ,       - .                ,    ,    ,   .            .


* * *

       -      ( 00-04-00164)     ( Research Support Scheme of the Open Society Foundation 777/1997[8 -    (Open Society Foundations)       (OSI Assistance Foundation) 30  2015         .]).         ,        -  .      ..  (), ..  ()  ..  ().  ,        ,   , , , , , ,      :       . , ,          .













    ,    ,  .   , ,       ,  - ,      ,    (    XIX    XX.)[9 -   .:  ..      . , 18871900. . 13;     ,   . ., 1932. . :  .. -.    -   . I.     . ., 1887;  ..      ,         19221972 . ., 1974.].      -          ,  .    ,         , ,          ,    .            ;    ,     ; -    -  ,     ,   ; ,      -   ,     ;      -.   ,        ,              [10 - .        ,     .. :  .. ,     ,    //    /  . .. , .. , .. -. ., 1908. .I. . 396422 (. 16);  .. :  ..  . ., 1941. . 290,      ,  ..   :   / ., . ., .   . .. . ., 1991. . 288301 (121134).   ,    XX.        - :  ,  ,        .].      - : -,         ,              . -,  -     ,  -   - ,               ,             -.

 ,            ,      ,     .                 .      :       ,   ,        XIX   XX.           .    ,        ,                .

  ,         (    )[11 -  ,        : [- ..]  . ., 1819.     ,   .  . ,   2.]  ,   , ,  ,   .     ..               [12 - .:  ..   . -  //      ( ). .; ., 1897. .I. . LLV ( :  ..      // . 1873. . 104. 3);  ..   .      // . 1902. 2. . 60;  ..   .. . . I / . .. - // :  . .; ., 1993. . 2. . 343, 345.].        ,   -   .              ,   1844.      [13 - .:       / ., . .. . ., 1995. . 369444, 467474;  ..   . . LIIILIV; [ .,  .,  .]     ( .. )   . ., 1914;  ..      //   . 2011. 111. . 288315.            2.].        (  20 )           [14 - [ ..]    . ., 1844.  ,           ,   ..  (. 1872. 4. . V.. 2138; 1873. 1. . V.. 15).].           .           (       ) ,        :       ,    ,     1809.[15 -          XIX   XX. .:  ..         . ., 1917.       . ,   2.],        ()  ,    ,     ,    ,   1834.       -[16 -  ..       : . 1.     // . 1872. . 1. . 111174.].         XIX.,       .

   ,      ,    ,        ,        ,     .            ,   37   ,     .  ,        .         ,          :



            :     ;     :          , , ,    ,   ,      .  ,   ,   [17 - [ ..]    . . 146.].


  .        I,         .     ,     ,   .    ,              ,  .      ,        [18 -  ..   . . LIVLV.].

 .. ,    ,   ,       .. ,   1845.    ,    .. [19 - [ ..]    . ., 1845.          :  ..     . , 1862. . III.. 1240 ( ).]. , ,     :       .     ,         .    , ,  ,      ,           .

 ,   -                      ,        1840- . ,         ,     ,          ,          XIX.,      ,         .        :    (-, [20 - .   ,   4.]),          ,          ,        .  ,         ,    ,        .

   -       .       ,   ,     ,           ,      III:



  ,        ,                       III,     ,   ,  . -         (     !),    ,   ,            . <>    :  ,    ,       ,     ,     ,   ,      ?       :  ,       ;  ,       [21 -  ..     . . III.. 229.].


         ,  .           .

             .  ,  ,    .-,        ,    ,       ,      .     :    ,   ,   ;      ,          .    ,          [22 - [ ..]    . . 139140.].  , ,   :       1810- . .. ,               .  ,  :    ,         ,    .         [23 - .. 1473. . 1. 1. . 296296 .].

  (       )     ,    .        ,      ,   .   ,           ( ,  ,     , ..  ). ,            ,     . ,       -.         .   -   , ..    ,          [24 - .:  ..   . ., 2012. . 117146.].           , ,              ,             (,   )    [25 - Potz M. Voluntary Costly Signals in Religious Communities: A Political Interpretation // Method & Theory in the Study of Religion. 2023. Vol. 35. N 4. P. 342368.].    , ..  ,             (    ),      ,  -    [26 - Maltsev V. Economic Effects of Voluntary Religious Castration on the Informal Provision of Cooperation: The Case of the Russian Skoptsy sect // European Economic Review. 2022. Vol. 145 [-: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0014292122000526 ( : 03.03.2025)].].   ,        ,             .  , ,           :  ,    ,            .

     ,       ,   30  ,  1872.,             .                .. ,    -         ,       [27 -  . [.] -  . ., 1872.].    ,     - ,           .        , ,      .               ,      ,      ,       .  ,              ,    .             1740- .,               (         .  2  ).  ,      XVIII.     , ,                  - [28 -  . . 162.].        XIX   [29 -  . . 162164.].

   1872.          .           .. .      .   (     )       ..        ,                 [30 -  ..    .   (     ). ., 1872. . 2.].            :           . ,  ,      .              ;           (,         ,   , , -,     ).   (,    )     ,       .           [31 -  ..       XVIII  //    ,      . ., 1889. . 6. . II.. 77199.] ,         .   ,        , ,   ,    . ,       .    -   ,      ,    . ,   ,                     .     ,            ,     1689.      [32 - . ,   2.].              XVIII.  ,       :          .   ,  1882.,         ,        XIX.[33 -  ..       XVIII   XIX  //  . 1882. 5. . 579.]      ,        18301840- .          ,          ,       .

   ,  ,        XIX.  , ,    ,         ,         (  ,     ).        .      ,    .

            1860- .       I     ,     . ,             XVIII,     XIX.       , , ,    .         (),     ,    ,        (),        1840- .               .         . ,   ( , ,   ),       (      ),         .   ,        .. ,    1850- .         ,   1869.    [34 -  . [.]  .      . , 1869.].        ,     .           (),               ,    1840- .   .      ,   ,        ,    ,          ,      [35 - .:  ..   ? (  ) // . 1915. 4. . 409426,    2  .].            (.. . ..)[36 -  . [.]  . . IIIIV.] ,      ,            [37 -  ,         ,           .]. ( , ,            ,  .. -    [38 - .:  .. ( ).    (  ). ., 1909. . VI.. 317318.].) ,               XIX.,          .    ,      ,       ,      .  , ,       .  ,            .         .      ,     ?       .   ,       85     (  , -,      )[39 -  . [.]  . . 101199.].  ,      ,         ,        .

        ,           .  , ,   .         (1867)[40 -  .        //    . 1867. . . 89119. . . 333365 ( ).],       - (, , ,   )  - (, ,   )[41 -  . . 91.],      :      ,             . ,   ![42 -  . . 105.]                XX.[43 - ., :  .      . , 1910;  .   . :       . ., 1910;  ..      . ., 1915; .]

      -   .. ,    18601870- .     ,      (103 )[44 - .:  .. ,    . ., 1879. . 71113 (  :  .    //  . 1869. 9. . 418481);  .   ()    //    . ., 1871. . IV.. IXV, 1154.].                ,              .       ,    .. -    ,           ,             .   ,      ,            . ,  ,    ,              , , ,    ,                .     [45 -  ..   ()   . . II.].  ,        :



   ,      ,             ;      ,    -                     . <>  ,   , ,  ;         ,   , ..          ,    , .. . <>    ,   ,            , ,   ,   <> ,        ,                         . <>  ,          ,       .            ,  ,         . ,    ,     ,      ?[46 -  .. ,    . . 8486.       ..     (1868).          .  .:  ..   . ., 1963. . II.. 160169.]


    ,     18601870- .      :   ,  ,     ,         .         (   )             .      ,      .

 ,  , ,    ,        .           1868.  ,        .  , ,         ,    -  ,    -      .   ,        , ,   , ,     ( . ..)          ,        ,         ,    ,   [47 -  ..   ()   . . XV.]. ,    ,   ,     . , ,  -       (   ,         ).            ,       ,     .  ,        -  .  ,      ,        ,     XVIII.,      ,   ,     ..     XIX .

,             ,       .              1860-  1870- .       .. , .. -  .. .

 ..  (18351872)   .  1858.        - ,       (1859),     ,    ,     .. .                .           (, 18601862),         ,        (, 1863).  1862.    ,      .              .       -,  , -,   .  1865.    ,          .         ,   [48 - .:    // . ., 1897. . 8. . 609611.].

  1860- .    -    .     ,             ,       1867.,    ,    [49 -  ..  . I //  . 1867. . 174. 10. . 1. . 583619;  .  .   // . 1869. . . I.. 130;  .  . II.   // . 1869. . . II.. 136.].      (       )      (   ,        )           ,         .                      ,       .   ,         ,           (.     2).     ,                     .. [50 -   ,   1867.    III     ,       (          1862.)     ,     :  ..  / .  . ; . . . .  //  . 1941. . 41/42. . II.. 326.   ,         .]  .           ,       ,              . ,  ,            :



      ໠                .   -,     ,        ,     ,     (),  ,   ,  .   ,    [51 -  ..  . II.  . . 2122.]


 ,        ,   ,          ,            .. -[52 -   1868.,  , .    ,          ,   . , ,            ,         :  .. ( ). . ., 1909. . VI.. 318.         : ., ,             :  . . 359.  , ,   ,                        ( .. . . 289),        .].

   folk-lore,   fake-lore        [53 - .:  .. .. - //     (  XIX.) / . . .. . ., 1982. . 94130.],              .  ,        .

                 :  (    ),  (     ,     1868  1869. [54 -  ..   //  . 1868. . 75. 5. . 570;  .   //  . 1869. . 80. 3. . 311416.        :  .. ( ). . ., 1909. . VI.. 251299, 300422.])   (          [55 -  ..       . . 1.     // . 1872. . 1. . 53174;  . . 2.         // . 1872. . 2. . 37205;  . . 3.  ,       1826  // . 1872. . 3. . 27326;  . . 4.  ,          . 18251833 (. 1872. . 4. . 17139);  . . 5.  ,         1834  1844  // . 1873. . 1. . 1262.]).  , ,       ,      ,       -       [56 - ., ,  ,      :  .. ( ). .. VI.. 300301.].        ,        ,          [57 -  . . 318.].   ,            ,           .  ,   .. ,             [58 -  . [.]      //  . 1870. . . 1920, 2529 (2- ).].       .  , ,      -    , , ,    .

, ,    ,      ,           . -,   ,            .  ,               .        ,     ,        .           ,           . -,      ,    , ,        .  ,          . ,  ,     ,    .    ,        ,        ,         .

   -          ,     1860- .,       , .. [59 - .:  ..   . ., 18681873. . IIV.],            .         ,                [60 -   ,  ,      .. :  . [.]  . II.  (   ); III. ; IV.  //  . 1867. . 173. 7. . 482521;  ..    . VII.    //  . 1869. . 183. 4. . 334338),              .].

       18601870- .    ..            [61 -  ,      -  .:  .. . . ., 1883;  ..   .   //  .. . ., 1908. . 3. . ICIX;  ..  :      // Lebenskunst  Kunstleben:     XVIIIXX. M?nchen, 1998. C. 89123.].         -          ,      , ,          .  ,   .. ,              ,     ,       (  )        ,   -  [62 -      .:  ..     . 17001740. ., 2000. . 7879.].                    . ,     XVII.   ,      ,  ,           :     , ,   .



   ,  ,  - ,           <>  ,    ,      ,      ,     ,     ,      [63 - . :  ..    //  .. . ., 1906. . 1. . 463;  :  ..   . ., 1862.].


,     -,      ,  ,   . ,              ,       :



  -,   ,    ,  , -   ,       ,     [64 -  . . 464465.].


     ,                  - - .             :



         -   -      - . -, -,                      [65 - . :  ..     //  .. . ., 1906. . 1. . 606;  :  ..     // . 1867. 10. . 319848; 11. . 138168; 12. . 170200.].


  ,          ,         .  ,    :    1864.    ,   ,    1860- .      .

      ,     (   ,  , ..   .. ,    . [66 - .:  ..         . ., 1881;  .   (  ). ., 1904. . 12;  .       . ., 1905;  .      . ., 1905;  .   . (   ). ., 1917;  .  :    . ., 1881.]),      -     ,         .

       18501870- .              ..  (18541911;         .. ,     XX.     ).  1883.    (575 )     [67 -  ., .    . , 1883.],           1880- . ,       .      :                        ,     ( ,       ).       :            ,      [68 -  . . 336.].   ,               (     )        .           ,   - .

     ,         .   ,   ,    1880-,    1890- .,      [69 -   :  ..       XVIII. . 77159;  ..       // . 1887. . 2. . I.. 189 ( ).            17331739  17451756.].             XX.  , -,          , -,          ,       [70 -        .: Hansen-L?ve A.A. Allgemeine H?retik, russische Sekten und ihre Literarisierung in der Moderne // Wiener Slawistischer Almanach. Sonderband 41: Ortodoxien und H?resien in den slavischen Literaturen: Beitr. der gleichnaminen Tagung vom 6.9. Sept. 1994 in Fribourg / Hrsg. von Rolf Fieguth. Wien, 1996. S. 171294 (   : -˸ ..          //     / . . . , . . , 1997. . 153226);  ..   :     . ., 1996;  .  (,   ). ., 1998; Engelstein L. Having it both ways: Rozanov, modenity and the Skopcy // On the Verge: Russian Thought Between the Nineteenth and the Twentieth Centuries / Ed. F. Bj?rling. Lund, 2001. P 115. (Slavica Lundensia; 21).].

   1880- .           .               .  18801890- .        .       廠    1896. (   ; 1899.     ).     ,   ,       .     ,     ,     ,      ,                .

 ,           ,    ..   .. . ,      ,     ,       ,   19121917.    ,    -  [71 -    .:    //   /  . .       II.., 2000. .I. . 340341.].          .    1910- .           [72 -  ..      . ., 1915. . 1. . . 13;  .     . ., 19161917. . 12;  .      // . 1916. 78. . 360386; 11. . 641661.].  ,       :          ,            ,      ,   .             ,              .

..       .       [73 - ., :  ..         // . 1903. 13. . 311325; 14. . 438454; 16. . 703714.], , -,     .         19141915.   [74 -  ..        // . 1914. . 1. 14. . 6686, 235261;  .      // . 1914. . 3. 12. . 494509;  .   ,  ,     // . 1915. 2. . 179229;  .   ?].  ,  1915.         [75 -  ..   . ., 1915.],   1917.      ,  ,   [76 -  ..         .].

 ,          ,    .  1916.      ,        [77 -  ..    ( ..      . ., 1915. . 1: . . IIII). ., 1916;  ..   . ., 1916.].     ,     ,    ,            .          ,           .

  ,      ,  .. ,   1908.       [78 -  ..      .  , 1908. . 1. . 1.      .].      ,               -.      -       :                . ,               .    1908.          ,       .           -        ().     ,   1909.     .      [79 -   .:  . [.]    //  . ., 1911. . XII. . 826830;  ..   :        // . 1998. 31. . 102122.].

           -.           ,   , , -    .     (      )  -   .      :      ,    - ,      . ,        -   .

    XX.            ( ,                  ),          ,  - .  , ,   :         ,  ,          ,        ,          [80 -           .. . , ,     ,              . ,    . ,  -       post factum.]. ,                      ;  ,       , , ,    [81 -  ..      . . 46.].  ,            .         -    :             -     XIX.[82 -  . . 135157, 175193.]         -        .             .       .

       ,        1910- .       .. : .. , .. , .. [83 -  .. ,     ,   . . 396422 (. 16);  . [.]    .      . ., 1912. . III;  ..    // . 1914. . IIIIV.. 373394;  .    // . 1915 (1916). . 107/108. 3/4. . 1561;  .  . ., 1919.].                 1890- .      ,          [84 - .:  ..          ..  //     .. .   . 1965. ., 1966. . 28. . 4395.].           .. [85 - .: - ..         . ., 1908. . 1. . 6973; Engelstein L. Castration and the Heavenly Kingdom: aRussian Folktale. Ithaca, 1999. P. 155158.]. ,        :             ,   ,     [86 -  ..  . . 2432.].                 .      ,         ,           ,      .       .  ,       ,                 .

       .. -,    19001910- .         [87 - - ..         . ., 1908. . 1. . . . .   . . . . . ; 1910. . 2.   ; 1909. . 3. -.  .  . .; 1911. . 4.  ; 1912. . 5.  ..  . . I; 1912. . 6.    . Christchurch, 1902; ., 1916. . 7. .   . (  3  7 ).    - .:  ..  (,   ). . 631674.].  ,          .   -      ( , ,     ),         ,          .          ; ,          ,      [88 - - ..         . . 4.].  1909. -        (  .. , ..   .)    1910- .      [89 - .: .. 2. . 5/68; . I. . 6/93.].  1920- . -                   . ,    ,     [90 -  ..     :   - // . .; ., 1996. . 19. . 275319.].

 1912.                  ,  ..   .. [91 -  ..,  ..   -. ., 1912 (  .. XXXV).].           , , , -,       .   716 , ,    ,           ,           .                 ,          . -,            ,  -.              ;           -,        .       . ,          :       ,   ,    .          .            ,         .      ,         ,      ,   ..       . ,          .           -        ,   ,         .  ,              .    ,  ,   3500 ,    1/6   ,         .     ,       ,   (  ,   , ),  ,   [92 -  ..,  ..   -. . VVI.]. ,            , , , .. ,   1912.     (-, )    ,     1904. ..       [93 -  ..   . ., 1912;      / . . .. . , 1904.].            .   -      ,                      .

   ,  ,         19001910- .,       . ,       ,         1917.    .    1920- .             ,           .

         (    )      - .   ,    1920- .      [94 - .   :  . [.]  .    // . 1929. 12(36). . 2528;  . [.]  . ., 1930 (2- .: ., 1931). . 130145;  .  (  ). ., 1930;  .  . (-). ., 1930;  .   (   -). , 1930;  ..    . ., 1974. . 2244; Engelstein L. Castration and the Heavenly Kingdom. P. 206218.].     ,         :         ,      ,      ,        .  ,        :              . , ,       ,      .

    ,    1930- .     , ,  .   2  -  ,    .          ,       .           .              ,   1939.  [95 - .:  ..  . ., 1996. . 160167.]. ,         ,                  .  ,    ,        ,    [96 - .   1930- .     :  ..    :   . 19201930 . ., 1999. . 264292.].   ,               [97 - .. , -,       1920-   1930- .,    -  1920-    1930- .,  , :     ,   2      .   1920-   , ,    ,   ,   2        ,  ,    1 -     ,    XVIIIXIX     .    .    :  ..  . . 163164.].

  19271928.      ,       . ,       ,   1929.               .          .   1930.        ,        ,    .         [98 -  ..    . . 3840.]. ,  1931.      [99 -  . . 45.].

      19201930- .    -,  .. . ,      : 1935.         ,           [100 -    .:  ..    (     ) // . 1994. 3. . 132155;     :  ..     .   - . ., 1998. . 4245;  ..     . . 8284.].    ,             ,        .  1929.       ,       .       ..    -,     .. ,     [101 -      .:  ..  .  II.      ,      // . 1995. 4. . 79; Engelstein L. Castration and the Heavenly Kingdom. P. 214218.].            1930. (     ).          [102 -  . [.]  . ., 1930 (2- .: ., 1931).].  19311935.     ,          .  1937.         [103 -  . [.]   . .; ., 1937.].     1937.,        ..                  .        : 1938.    ,       л (   )        .  1941.     ,     ,                    .  1953.       .

       ,         ,         ,   .                  .   [104 - .: Frazer J.G. The Golden Bough. Ware, 1993. P. 347352.]        [105 -  . [.]  . . 1213.],  ,           :     ,        [106 -  . [.]  . . 17.].         :     (. ..)        ,  ,            - .      , ,  , , , ,  ,     , -   [107 -  . . 32.].             :         ,     ,   ,         .         :           .         ,   XIX   XX.,         (    ,    ).          ,   ,        .  ,            ( ,    ..).

          :                 .             .        :  1930- .        ,      ,           .   ,  ,  ,        ,    ,    .            .          ,      ,           [108 -  . [.]   . . 5.].              1930.        :               [109 -  . . 105.].          ,            , -, :  ,                  ;      -       ,      -,   [110 -  . . 26, 29.].   -         :               ,     ,    [111 -  . . 52.]. ,        ,      -    :       .       ,   , ,    . <>   -        [112 -  . [.]   . . 2829.].

   ,       -   ,  .. . ,    ,  ,      ,    -.  19601970- .            ,   ,          [113 - .:  ..    . ., 1960;  .     . ., 1965;  .    . ., 1969;  .      . ., 1971;  .      . ., 1973;  .    . ., 1974;  .     :  . ., 1977  .].   19501960- .      -       (,  , )    [114 -    .:  . ., 1961;  ..      . . 167218. . :  ..            //     . ., 1961. . 9. . 77112               .        :   .. 1. . XII. . 1.].  ,   1970- .       ,            [115 -  ..    . . 4961.].

       .  -        -         .           ,             .                  :         [116 - ., :  ..      . . 57.].        .  1959.          軠   ,   1820- .          ,         ,     .       ..            ,    ,      [117 -   .. 1. . XII. . 1. 15. .:  ..    . . 139152;  .      . . 181183.  ,  ,    .].          :           .

,   ,       ,          -    -.    ,   ,   ,         . ,            .

        .     .  ,    XX.,    ,  -       . [118 - Grass K.K. Die russischen Sekten. Leipzig, 1907. Bd. I: Die Gottsleute oder Chl?sten. Leipzig, 1914. Bd. II: Die Wiessen Tauben oder Skopzen; Idem. Andre Blochin und seine Gemeinde. Jurjew (Dorpat), 1913. ,       -   ,    .],      .-. ,       ,    [119 - Sverac J.-B. La secte russe des Hommes-de-Dieu. Paris, 1906.].   ,  1980- .   .    ,  ,   ,    ,        XIXXX.[120 - Clay J.E. Gods People in the Early Eighteenth Century. The Uglich Affair of 1717 // Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovitique. 1985. Vol. XXVI (I). P. 69124; Idem. The Theological Origins of the Christ-Faith (Khristovshchina). P. 2142.]       1717.  ,                  ,        .       ,              .       .

        -  1990- .      [121 -  ..         (  ) // . .    .  . ., 1996. . 2. . 210232;  ..     //   :  VI -  . ., 1998. . 4749;  .. -    XVIII          //  :   / . .. , .. . ., 2000. . 197204.],          ,       .  ()  ..  ()[122 -   2024.           .],         ,       [123 - .:  ..  :   // . 1995. 4. . 131163;  .   :     ;  .  (,   ); Etkind A. Russian Sects Still Seem Obscure // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History. 2001. Vol. 2(1). Winter. P. 165181,     . Engelstein L. Paradigms, Pathologies, and other Clues to Russian Spiritual Culture: Some Post-Soviet Thoughts // Slavic Review. 1998. Vol. 57. Winter. P. 864877; Eadem. Castration and the Heavenly Kingdom; Eadem. Having it both ways.].

          ,      .        ,    ,    ,      1760- .    1930- .   ,    .         :   ,    ,          .               (  ),           -    XIX.          .      ,        :          ,    .  ,        : ,         ,            (.   ,   4).            -       .      ,  ,   ,           .

, , .   ,     XX.,       -,              ,               .  ,    ,           ,          .    ,    ,   ,   ,    ()    .       , ,              ,       [124 - Etkind A. Russian Sects Still Seem Obscure. P. 177.].

   , ,                           .  ,      .. ,  ,       ,           .  ,             ,        ,    -  XIX   XX.        ,   ,         ,              ,      -  ,               .    ,             , , , , ,          ,  .     ,         ,        ,   ,       :        .        :       ,     -,         , ,  ,    ..         ,              .  ,            .


* * *

     ,      ,             [125 - . ,            :  .. ( ).          :         //    2021:  -  . ., 2022. C. 7392.],            [126 -     ,          - ,   ,         .].             ..   .. .    [127 -  ..  .     . ., 2015.],   2015.    ,                17331739  17451756. (.     2).     ,     ,        .        ,      ,           .     ,  ,  ,             ,          , ..    I    (    ,   ,        ..).      ,        ,  .   : ,  ,               [128 -  ..  . . 55, 6869, 9091.].  ,         ( ,   )  :



         ,     ,   / .            ,    .      ,     . <>      (, ,  )     ,    ,  .                         ,         [129 -  . . 34.].


, ,      ,       ,     ,    (1691, .    2)          .

         ,     .  ,          , , ,     ()     .                ,        蔻[130 -  ..  . . 57.].     ,         ,        ,          :               ,          [131 -  . . 70.].

 .. ,     ,      .              . ,       XVIII.     ,       ,  ,             [132 -  ..    :    . , 2020. . 75.].              I         .   ,    , ,         ,       [133 -  . . 100.].  ,          ,          [134 -  ..    :    . . 103.].   ,       ,      ,    [135 -  . . 155.].  ,         ,   ,      .                  .  , , ,          [136 -  .].             . , ,  ,        1717.     (.    2)       ,      XVII.,  ,   ,        ,       [137 -  . . 7172.].       ,                XVII   XVIII. (  ,   ,    ,    ,    ).

 ,  ,   ,      ,        -     .  ,   .   ,               .          ,   ,  .         ,        ,    , .

      ,       ,      . .      ,          [138 - Clay E. Traders, Vagabonds, Incarnate Christs, and Pilgrims: The Religious Network of Danilo Filippov, 16501850 // Poverty and Prosperity in the Middle Ages and Renaissance. Turnhout, 2012. P. 225239.] (.    2). ,      ..   .. [139 -  ..    :          // . 2019. 1. . 131132;  ..   ,   ,    // , ,      . 2020. 38(3). . 6383;  .  : 1747  // Studia Religiosa Rossica:    . 2023. 2. . 96110.],        XVIII.      .      1760.     ,  ,   ,     1740- .   [140 - Clay E. The Quaker Heresy in Siberia // Canadian-American Slavic Studies. 2017. Vol. 51. P. 122136].         .. ,   -   [141 -  ..    .  I //  . 2017. 3(39). . 4159;  .    .  II //  . 2017. 4(40). . 4769.].              ,      ,  ,     .        ໠   1870- .       (.    2).

         ,       ,               . ,  ,          . ,   ,        ,     .     , , ,    ,     , ,      ,        -  ,    .     :    ,     .. ,      ..        .. ,    2024.     :  .     ..     ,    , ,               .       ,           .







,    ,     .       - ,   ,     ,      .  ,          ,     (   )       :   (.. 796),     (.. 1284),      (.. 1473),       XVIII. (.. 301302),          XIX   XX.     (.. 1431)[142 -    (4206  )  -                19121916.     1792  1916.   145   30     ( ..  // .. 1431. . 1. . IIV).      ,    ..   .. .],    (.. 1183).

,     ,      ,   ,     ,       ,       .

         ,      (,    ..),  .          ,       .   ,    1910- .   .. - (.. 2. . 5/68. . I. . 6/93),         (, 1904),       .. .

,          ,    XX. (. ).

,     ,         -  XVIIIXIX.                -  - [143 - .  . , .   , . , .. , .. , .. , .. , ..   .]. ,          ,        ..      ,      -.            ,   ,   ,         .          ,             , ,      .

    -          . ,                 ,  -  . , , ,       (    )     (   trial-lore        ),       ,     ..         , -,  :            ,      .              ,        17451756.       ,   ,       ,   ,       ,            .      ,    ,        ,    .

    XIX.    ,    .     I      .                 : ,        ,       , .    .         .      ,        . ,  ,  ,   [144 -       .:  . [.] -  . . 116117.].       , ,    -  ,   1901. ;      ,   ,   :



                  , ,   ,      ,    ,        ,          ,         .                ,    ,   ,  ,   ,    .   , , ,   ,  ,      ,             [145 - .. 2. . 5/68. 287. . 2.].


        ..   (   1860- .  ).         ,    :      ;       .                 ,     [146 -  ..   . ., 1872. .I. . 123.].

,            (.  4  ),       .               ,      . ,        , ,  ,  :         ,        .

      trial-lore,    ,       .            ,   1839.    () (      )[147 - .:  ..      . . 1. . . 1. . 7890.].      , ,   ,                  . -           .  ,         .  ,        ,     ,  :      (          ),      ,     , -,        -   [148 -  ..   -  XVIIXIX. ., 1967. . 295305.].

     .     ,    ,     trial-lore,           .      :     -     ,      ?          -[149 - : Writing Culture: The Poetics and Politics of Ethnography / Eds. J. Clliford, G. Marcus. Berkeley, 1986 (,  , . .: Rosaldo R. From the Door of His Tent: The Fieldworker and the Inquisitor. P. 7797,        ); Geertz Cl. Works and Lives: The Antropologist as Author. Stanford, 1988; Ginzburg C. The Inquisitor as Anthropologist // Ginzburg C. Clues, Myths and the Historical Method. Baltimore, 1989. P. 156164; Biddick K. The Shock of Medievalism. Durham; L., 1998. P. 105134.        .].             :          .

,           ,      ,     [150 - .:  ..       //    : . .  ..  (18951970). ., 1975. . 2643;  .    :  . ., 1986. . 107176; Fine E.C. The Folklore Text: From Performance to Print. Bloomington, 1984;  .    : , ,  // Senosios ra?tijos ir tautosakos saveika: kulturine Lietuvos Didziosios Kunigaik?tystes patirtis. Vilnius, 1998. P. 159175;  ..     :    //  : .  .. . ., 1999. . 289297.],        ,     (    )  .    ,      , ..   ().

        (    ,      )         [151 - Degh L., Vazsonyi A. The Hypothesis of Multi-Conduit Transmission in Folklore // Folklore: Performance and Communication / Eds. D. Ben-Amos, K. Goldstein. The Hague; Paris, 1975. P. 207252; Fine G.A. The Third Force in American Folklore: Folk Narratives and Social Structures // Fabula. 1988. Bd. 29. Heft 3/4 (Folk-Narrative Research in the U.S.A. /Guest editor W.F. H. Nicolaisen). P. 350351.].       ,      .          .    ,            ,    .          ,          .           ,        :    (intended meaning)[152 - .: Bellman B.L. Ethnohermeneutics: On the Interpretation of Intended Meaning among the Kpelle of Liberia // Language and Thought: Anthropological Issues / Eds. W.C. McCormack, St. A. Wurm. The Hague; Paris, 1972. P. 271282.],   ,   ,     ..   :         ?    ,  , ,         ?

         :  (    ),  (   ),           ( , ,   ..),    . ,   ,       .                     -   :                      [153 - Fine E.C. The Folklore Text: From Performance to Print. P. 9497.].

        .          .       ,     :  ()     ,     ,    ,       ,      .           ,            ,      .     ,     :             .      ,    ,       .         ,     .

,           ,       .     ,       ,   ,  .       ,   ,    ,  ,     ,  ,     .      :        ,     ,      ,     ?          ,      :     ,      .. ,                .

  ,  ,   ,       .     ,  ,   ,           .                  ,      .  ,       ,       ,  ,  ,   ,       .

,            ,   ()   ,    ,      .      ,           :          ,          ,       .    , ..     .       :         ,         .    :        .           .             :    ,  . ,     ,  :       ,      .                   .

   ,   trial-lore       ,      .   :         .     ,            .  ,                    ,               .        ,           . , ,   :  -        [154 - .   :  .   :  . ., 1999.],          ?     .  ,    , -,              .             ,     .   ,      ,           [155 - ., ,  .      :  . . Choses dites / . . .. . ., 1994. . 181207.]. ,             -    ,        XX .

,     .            ,      .  ,               .      -  -       ,        :  ,   . .            ,           -     ,       :



         .       ,    ,           .         ,    ,  ,   .  ,     컠      ,   [156 - Ginzburg C. The Inquisitor as Anthropologist. P. 159.].


   ,                    .        , ,    ..                       .


* * *

                 ,            .                        -    .     .            ,        ,    -  - .             -. ,               .              XVIIIXX.

      .       ;       ,        ;       .          , ,        .       .   ,             ,     :         . ., 1899 (: ., 1997).




 1.     


      (folk religion, religi?se Volkskunde, religion populaire)         [157 -        [,    .: Southwold M. True Buddhism and Village Buddhism in Shri Lanka // Religious Organization and Religious Experience / Ed. J. Davis. L.; N.Y., 1982. P. 137152. (A.S.A. Monograph; 21)],               .].         ,   ,     .  ,         ,         ,        ,              .                 .       , ,       , ,  ,        .          ,          , -  - .

                XX.[158 - .,  : Thomas K. Religion and the Decline of Magic. N.Y., 1971; Yoder D. Toward a Definition of Folk Religion // Symposium on Folk Religion / Ed. D. Yoder. P. 215 (Western Folklore. 1974. Vol. 33. N 1: Special issue); Brown P. The Cult of the Saints: Its Rise and Function in Latin Christianity. Chicago, 1981; Badone E. Introduction // Religious Orthodoxy and Popular Faith in European Society / Ed. E. Badone. Princeton, 1990. P. 321; Primiano L.N. Vernacular Religion and the Search for Method in Religious Folklife // Reflexivity and the Study of Belief / Ed. D.J. Hufford. P. 3756 (Western Folklore. 1995. Vol. 54. N 1: Special issue); Crummey R. Old Belief as Popular Religion: New Approaches // Slavic Review. 1993. Vol. 52. N 4. P. 700712; Levin E. Dvoeverie and Popular Religion // Seeking God. The Recovery of Religious Identity in Orthodox Russia, Ukraine, and Georgia / Ed. S.K. Batalden. DeKalb, 1993. P. 3152; Stark L. The Folk Interpretation of Orthodox Religion in Karelia from an Anthropological Perspective // Studies in Folklore and Popular Religion. Tartu, 1996. Vol. 1: Papers Delivered at the Symposium Walter Anderson and Folklore Studies Today / Ed. ?. Valk. P. 143157.         .:  ..     .   - . ., 1998. . 712, 1761;  ..     . 17001740. ., 2000. . 7588.],                  .        ,         .        .

   .. ,   ,      [159 - .,  :  ..   (      ) //   . ., 1995. . 211240;  .   (   ) //  :    . ., 1995. . 110176.].             ,             .  ,       (   ,     ..),           .       -  ,       .   . Ҹ.  ,          . ,        ,     ,            .          .       .               ,            ,             ?                 ?       ,      .       ,            - ,    .   (  ,        )         ,   ,       .      (  )    ,      (     ) ,    . ,       ,                 . ,      ,       ,        .

       ,         ,      ..      [160 -  ..      // . .    .  . ., 1998. . 4. . 90110.].     1990- .,          ,   ,       ,   ,     .     .   ,      XIX.       ,           .   ,    ,   1917.       , ,    ,                  [161 -  ..     . . 9192.]. ,         ,       ,        .

        XX.     (             ;      ;    ),                 .  ,     (  )      .      XIX.          ,   :  ,              .      ,      :         . , ,   XIX   XX.     ,            .       ,       ( ,  ),    , -   , , - .

             .        ,        ..    ,   1990- .[162 - .:  ..      // . 1994. 3. . 35;  .    :   ,       // . 1995. 5. . 7783;  .       XX  (  ) //  . , 1999. 1. . 819.      :  ..       :       . ., 2000. . 331342.]              ,  ,   ,     ,   ,    ,              .            , ,              .    ,       (  , ),       ,  ,   ,         ,   -  .

 ,    - ,    ,           ,     ,     - . -,    -  .

   ,     ,        ,       .           ,       ,   ( . institutio  , , ).           .      ,       .      ,        ,  , , .      ,     .    ,  ,         .




  .


   .

   ,     (https://www.litres.ru/pages/biblio_book/?art=73826848)  .

      Visa, MasterCard, Maestro,    ,   ,     ,  PayPal, WebMoney, ., QIWI ,       .



notes








1


        :  ()     ,    : .. 1431. . 1. 914. . 21 .




2


 ..      .  , 1908. . 1. . 1.      . .I.




3


     .:  ..  :   .     . , 2015. . 1. . 2850.




4


Meyer B. Mediation and Immediacy: Sensational Forms, Semiotic Ideologies, and the Question of the Medium // A Companion to the Anthropology of Religion / Ed. by J. Boddy and M. Lambek. Oxford, 2013. P. 315.




5


Ibid. P. 317320.




6


 ..     .  , 1914. . 11.




7


.  : Clay E. The Theological Origins of the Christ-Faith (Khristovshchina) // Russian History / Histoire Russe. 1988. Vol. 15. N 1. P. 2142.




8


   (Open Society Foundations)       (OSI Assistance Foundation) 30  2015         .




9


  .:  ..      . , 18871900. . 13;     ,   . ., 1932. . :  .. -.    -   . I.     . ., 1887;  ..      ,         19221972 . ., 1974.




10


.        ,     .. :  .. ,     ,    //    /  . .. , .. , .. -. ., 1908. .I. . 396422 (. 16);  .. :  ..  . ., 1941. . 290,      ,  ..   :   / ., . ., .   . .. . ., 1991. . 288301 (121134).   ,    XX.        - :  ,  ,        .




11


 ,        : [- ..]  . ., 1819.     ,   .  . ,   2.




12


.:  ..   . -  //      ( ). .; ., 1897. .I. . LLV ( :  ..      // . 1873. . 104. 3);  ..   .      // . 1902. 2. . 60;  ..   .. . . I / . .. - // :  . .; ., 1993. . 2. . 343, 345.




13


.:       / ., . .. . ., 1995. . 369444, 467474;  ..   . . LIIILIV; [ .,  .,  .]     ( .. )   . ., 1914;  ..      //   . 2011. 111. . 288315.            2.




14


[ ..]    . ., 1844.  ,           ,   ..  (. 1872. 4. . V.. 2138; 1873. 1. . V.. 15).




15


         XIX   XX. .:  ..         . ., 1917.       . ,   2.




16


 ..       : . 1.     // . 1872. . 1. . 111174.




17


[ ..]    . . 146.




18


 ..   . . LIVLV.




19


[ ..]    . ., 1845.          :  ..     . , 1862. . III.. 1240 ( ).




20


.   ,   4.




21


 ..     . . III.. 229.




22


[ ..]    . . 139140.




23


.. 1473. . 1. 1. . 296296 .




24


.:  ..   . ., 2012. . 117146.




25


Potz M. Voluntary Costly Signals in Religious Communities: A Political Interpretation // Method & Theory in the Study of Religion. 2023. Vol. 35. N 4. P. 342368.




26


Maltsev V. Economic Effects of Voluntary Religious Castration on the Informal Provision of Cooperation: The Case of the Russian Skoptsy sect // European Economic Review. 2022. Vol. 145 [-: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0014292122000526 ( : 03.03.2025)].




27


 . [.] -  . ., 1872.




28


 . . 162.




29


 . . 162164.




30


 ..    .   (     ). ., 1872. . 2.




31


 ..       XVIII  //    ,      . ., 1889. . 6. . II.. 77199.




32


. ,   2.




33


 ..       XVIII   XIX  //  . 1882. 5. . 579.




34


 . [.]  .      . , 1869.




35


.:  ..   ? (  ) // . 1915. 4. . 409426,    2  .




36


 . [.]  . . IIIIV.




37


 ,         ,           .




38


.:  .. ( ).    (  ). ., 1909. . VI.. 317318.




39


 . [.]  . . 101199.




40


 .        //    . 1867. . . 89119. . . 333365 ( ).




41


 . . 91.




42


 . . 105.




43


., :  .      . , 1910;  .   . :       . ., 1910;  ..      . ., 1915; .




44


.:  .. ,    . ., 1879. . 71113 (  :  .    //  . 1869. 9. . 418481);  .   ()    //    . ., 1871. . IV.. IXV, 1154.




45


 ..   ()   . . II.




46


 .. ,    . . 8486.       ..     (1868).          .  .:  ..   . ., 1963. . II.. 160169.




47


 ..   ()   . . XV.




48


.:    // . ., 1897. . 8. . 609611.




49


 ..  . I //  . 1867. . 174. 10. . 1. . 583619;  .  .   // . 1869. . . I.. 130;  .  . II.   // . 1869. . . II.. 136.




50


  ,   1867.    III     ,       (          1862.)     ,     :  ..  / .  . ; . . . .  //  . 1941. . 41/42. . II.. 326.   ,         .




51


 ..  . II.  . . 2122.




52


  1868.,  , .    ,          ,   . , ,            ,         :  .. ( ). . ., 1909. . VI.. 318.         : ., ,             :  . . 359.  , ,   ,                        ( .. . . 289),        .




53


.:  .. .. - //     (  XIX.) / . . .. . ., 1982. . 94130.




54


 ..   //  . 1868. . 75. 5. . 570;  .   //  . 1869. . 80. 3. . 311416.        :  .. ( ). . ., 1909. . VI.. 251299, 300422.




55


 ..       . . 1.     // . 1872. . 1. . 53174;  . . 2.         // . 1872. . 2. . 37205;  . . 3.  ,       1826  // . 1872. . 3. . 27326;  . . 4.  ,          . 18251833 (. 1872. . 4. . 17139);  . . 5.  ,         1834  1844  // . 1873. . 1. . 1262.




56


., ,  ,      :  .. ( ). .. VI.. 300301.




57


 . . 318.




58


 . [.]      //  . 1870. . . 1920, 2529 (2- ).




59


.:  ..   . ., 18681873. . IIV.




60


  ,  ,      .. :  . [.]  . II.  (   ); III. ; IV.  //  . 1867. . 173. 7. . 482521;  ..    . VII.    //  . 1869. . 183. 4. . 334338),              .




61


 ,      -  .:  .. . . ., 1883;  ..   .   //  .. . ., 1908. . 3. . ICIX;  ..  :      // Lebenskunst  Kunstleben:     XVIIIXX. M?nchen, 1998. C. 89123.




62


     .:  ..     . 17001740. ., 2000. . 7879.




63


. :  ..    //  .. . ., 1906. . 1. . 463;  :  ..   . ., 1862.




64


 . . 464465.




65


. :  ..     //  .. . ., 1906. . 1. . 606;  :  ..     // . 1867. 10. . 319848; 11. . 138168; 12. . 170200.




66


.:  ..         . ., 1881;  .   (  ). ., 1904. . 12;  .       . ., 1905;  .      . ., 1905;  .   . (   ). ., 1917;  .  :    . ., 1881.




67


 ., .    . , 1883.




68


 . . 336.




69


  :  ..       XVIII. . 77159;  ..       // . 1887. . 2. . I.. 189 ( ).            17331739  17451756.




70


       .: Hansen-L?ve A.A. Allgemeine H?retik, russische Sekten und ihre Literarisierung in der Moderne // Wiener Slawistischer Almanach. Sonderband 41: Ortodoxien und H?resien in den slavischen Literaturen: Beitr. der gleichnaminen Tagung vom 6.9. Sept. 1994 in Fribourg / Hrsg. von Rolf Fieguth. Wien, 1996. S. 171294 (   : -˸ ..          //     / . . . , . . , 1997. . 153226);  ..   :     . ., 1996;  .  (,   ). ., 1998; Engelstein L. Having it both ways: Rozanov, modenity and the Skopcy // On the Verge: Russian Thought Between the Nineteenth and the Twentieth Centuries / Ed. F. Bj?rling. Lund, 2001. P 115. (Slavica Lundensia; 21).




71


   .:    //   /  . .       II.., 2000. .I. . 340341.




72


 ..      . ., 1915. . 1. . . 13;  .     . ., 19161917. . 12;  .      // . 1916. 78. . 360386; 11. . 641661.




73


., :  ..         // . 1903. 13. . 311325; 14. . 438454; 16. . 703714.




74


 ..        // . 1914. . 1. 14. . 6686, 235261;  .      // . 1914. . 3. 12. . 494509;  .   ,  ,     // . 1915. 2. . 179229;  .   ?




75


 ..   . ., 1915.




76


 ..         .




77


 ..    ( ..      . ., 1915. . 1: . . IIII). ., 1916;  ..   . ., 1916.




78


 ..      .  , 1908. . 1. . 1.      .




79


  .:  . [.]    //  . ., 1911. . XII. . 826830;  ..   :        // . 1998. 31. . 102122.




80


          .. . , ,     ,              . ,    . ,  -       post factum.




81


 ..      . . 46.




82


 . . 135157, 175193.




83


 .. ,     ,   . . 396422 (. 16);  . [.]    .      . ., 1912. . III;  ..    // . 1914. . IIIIV.. 373394;  .    // . 1915 (1916). . 107/108. 3/4. . 1561;  .  . ., 1919.




84


.:  ..          ..  //     .. .   . 1965. ., 1966. . 28. . 4395.




85


.: - ..         . ., 1908. . 1. . 6973; Engelstein L. Castration and the Heavenly Kingdom: aRussian Folktale. Ithaca, 1999. P. 155158.




86


 ..  . . 2432.




87


- ..         . ., 1908. . 1. . . . .   . . . . . ; 1910. . 2.   ; 1909. . 3. -.  .  . .; 1911. . 4.  ; 1912. . 5.  ..  . . I; 1912. . 6.    . Christchurch, 1902; ., 1916. . 7. .   . (  3  7 ).    - .:  ..  (,   ). . 631674.




88


- ..         . . 4.




89


.: .. 2. . 5/68; . I. . 6/93.




90


 ..     :   - // . .; ., 1996. . 19. . 275319.




91


 ..,  ..   -. ., 1912 (  .. XXXV).




92


 ..,  ..   -. . VVI.




93


 ..   . ., 1912;      / . . .. . , 1904.




94


.   :  . [.]  .    // . 1929. 12(36). . 2528;  . [.]  . ., 1930 (2- .: ., 1931). . 130145;  .  (  ). ., 1930;  .  . (-). ., 1930;  .   (   -). , 1930;  ..    . ., 1974. . 2244; Engelstein L. Castration and the Heavenly Kingdom. P. 206218.




95


.:  ..  . ., 1996. . 160167.




96


.   1930- .     :  ..    :   . 19201930 . ., 1999. . 264292.




97


.. , -,       1920-   1930- .,    -  1920-    1930- .,  , :     ,   2      .   1920-   , ,    ,   ,   2        ,  ,    1 -     ,    XVIIIXIX     .    .    :  ..  . . 163164.




98


 ..    . . 3840.




99


 . . 45.




100


   .:  ..    (     ) // . 1994. 3. . 132155;     :  ..     .   - . ., 1998. . 4245;  ..     . . 8284.




101


     .:  ..  .  II.      ,      // . 1995. 4. . 79; Engelstein L. Castration and the Heavenly Kingdom. P. 214218.




102


 . [.]  . ., 1930 (2- .: ., 1931).




103


 . [.]   . .; ., 1937.




104


.: Frazer J.G. The Golden Bough. Ware, 1993. P. 347352.




105


 . [.]  . . 1213.




106


 . [.]  . . 17.




107


 . . 32.




108


 . [.]   . . 5.




109


 . . 105.




110


 . . 26, 29.




111


 . . 52.




112


 . [.]   . . 2829.




113


.:  ..    . ., 1960;  .     . ., 1965;  .    . ., 1969;  .      . ., 1971;  .      . ., 1973;  .    . ., 1974;  .     :  . ., 1977  .




114


   .:  . ., 1961;  ..      . . 167218. . :  ..            //     . ., 1961. . 9. . 77112               .        :   .. 1. . XII. . 1.




115


 ..    . . 4961.




116


., :  ..      . . 57.




117


  .. 1. . XII. . 1. 15. .:  ..    . . 139152;  .      . . 181183.  ,  ,    .




118


Grass K.K. Die russischen Sekten. Leipzig, 1907. Bd. I: Die Gottsleute oder Chl?sten. Leipzig, 1914. Bd. II: Die Wiessen Tauben oder Skopzen; Idem. Andre Blochin und seine Gemeinde. Jurjew (Dorpat), 1913. ,       -   ,    .




119


Sverac J.-B. La secte russe des Hommes-de-Dieu. Paris, 1906.




120


Clay J.E. Gods People in the Early Eighteenth Century. The Uglich Affair of 1717 // Cahiers du monde Russe et Sovitique. 1985. Vol. XXVI (I). P. 69124; Idem. The Theological Origins of the Christ-Faith (Khristovshchina). P. 2142.




121


 ..         (  ) // . .    .  . ., 1996. . 2. . 210232;  ..     //   :  VI -  . ., 1998. . 4749;  .. -    XVIII          //  :   / . .. , .. . ., 2000. . 197204.




122


  2024.           .




123


.:  ..  :   // . 1995. 4. . 131163;  .   :     ;  .  (,   ); Etkind A. Russian Sects Still Seem Obscure // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History. 2001. Vol. 2(1). Winter. P. 165181,     . Engelstein L. Paradigms, Pathologies, and other Clues to Russian Spiritual Culture: Some Post-Soviet Thoughts // Slavic Review. 1998. Vol. 57. Winter. P. 864877; Eadem. Castration and the Heavenly Kingdom; Eadem. Having it both ways.




124


Etkind A. Russian Sects Still Seem Obscure. P. 177.




125


. ,            :  .. ( ).          :         //    2021:  -  . ., 2022. C. 7392.




126


    ,          - ,   ,         .




127


 ..  .     . ., 2015.




128


 ..  . . 55, 6869, 9091.




129


 . . 34.




130


 ..  . . 57.




131


 . . 70.




132


 ..    :    . , 2020. . 75.




133


 . . 100.




134


 ..    :    . . 103.




135


 . . 155.




136


 .




137


 . . 7172.




138


Clay E. Traders, Vagabonds, Incarnate Christs, and Pilgrims: The Religious Network of Danilo Filippov, 16501850 // Poverty and Prosperity in the Middle Ages and Renaissance. Turnhout, 2012. P. 225239.




139


 ..    :          // . 2019. 1. . 131132;  ..   ,   ,    // , ,      . 2020. 38(3). . 6383;  .  : 1747  // Studia Religiosa Rossica:    . 2023. 2. . 96110.




140


Clay E. The Quaker Heresy in Siberia // Canadian-American Slavic Studies. 2017. Vol. 51. P. 122136




141


 ..    .  I //  . 2017. 3(39). . 4159;  .    .  II //  . 2017. 4(40). . 4769.




142


   (4206  )  -                19121916.     1792  1916.   145   30     ( ..  // .. 1431. . 1. . IIV).      ,    ..   .. .




143


.  . , .   , . , .. , .. , .. , .. , ..   .




144


      .:  . [.] -  . . 116117.




145


.. 2. . 5/68. 287. . 2.




146


 ..   . ., 1872. .I. . 123.




147


.:  ..      . . 1. . . 1. . 7890.




148


 ..   -  XVIIXIX. ., 1967. . 295305.




149


: Writing Culture: The Poetics and Politics of Ethnography / Eds. J. Clliford, G. Marcus. Berkeley, 1986 (,  , . .: Rosaldo R. From the Door of His Tent: The Fieldworker and the Inquisitor. P. 7797,        ); Geertz Cl. Works and Lives: The Antropologist as Author. Stanford, 1988; Ginzburg C. The Inquisitor as Anthropologist // Ginzburg C. Clues, Myths and the Historical Method. Baltimore, 1989. P. 156164; Biddick K. The Shock of Medievalism. Durham; L., 1998. P. 105134.        .




150


.:  ..       //    : . .  ..  (18951970). ., 1975. . 2643;  .    :  . ., 1986. . 107176; Fine E.C. The Folklore Text: From Performance to Print. Bloomington, 1984;  .    : , ,  // Senosios ra?tijos ir tautosakos saveika: kulturine Lietuvos Didziosios Kunigaik?tystes patirtis. Vilnius, 1998. P. 159175;  ..     :    //  : .  .. . ., 1999. . 289297.




151


Degh L., Vazsonyi A. The Hypothesis of Multi-Conduit Transmission in Folklore // Folklore: Performance and Communication / Eds. D. Ben-Amos, K. Goldstein. The Hague; Paris, 1975. P. 207252; Fine G.A. The Third Force in American Folklore: Folk Narratives and Social Structures // Fabula. 1988. Bd. 29. Heft 3/4 (Folk-Narrative Research in the U.S.A. /Guest editor W.F. H. Nicolaisen). P. 350351.




152


.: Bellman B.L. Ethnohermeneutics: On the Interpretation of Intended Meaning among the Kpelle of Liberia // Language and Thought: Anthropological Issues / Eds. W.C. McCormack, St. A. Wurm. The Hague; Paris, 1972. P. 271282.




153


Fine E.C. The Folklore Text: From Performance to Print. P. 9497.




154


.   :  .   :  . ., 1999.




155


., ,  .      :  . . Choses dites / . . .. . ., 1994. . 181207.




156


Ginzburg C. The Inquisitor as Anthropologist. P. 159.




157


       [,    .: Southwold M. True Buddhism and Village Buddhism in Shri Lanka // Religious Organization and Religious Experience / Ed. J. Davis. L.; N.Y., 1982. P. 137152. (A.S.A. Monograph; 21)],               .




158


.,  : Thomas K. Religion and the Decline of Magic. N.Y., 1971; Yoder D. Toward a Definition of Folk Religion // Symposium on Folk Religion / Ed. D. Yoder. P. 215 (Western Folklore. 1974. Vol. 33. N 1: Special issue); Brown P. The Cult of the Saints: Its Rise and Function in Latin Christianity. Chicago, 1981; Badone E. Introduction // Religious Orthodoxy and Popular Faith in European Society / Ed. E. Badone. Princeton, 1990. P. 321; Primiano L.N. Vernacular Religion and the Search for Method in Religious Folklife // Reflexivity and the Study of Belief / Ed. D.J. Hufford. P. 3756 (Western Folklore. 1995. Vol. 54. N 1: Special issue); Crummey R. Old Belief as Popular Religion: New Approaches // Slavic Review. 1993. Vol. 52. N 4. P. 700712; Levin E. Dvoeverie and Popular Religion // Seeking God. The Recovery of Religious Identity in Orthodox Russia, Ukraine, and Georgia / Ed. S.K. Batalden. DeKalb, 1993. P. 3152; Stark L. The Folk Interpretation of Orthodox Religion in Karelia from an Anthropological Perspective // Studies in Folklore and Popular Religion. Tartu, 1996. Vol. 1: Papers Delivered at the Symposium Walter Anderson and Folklore Studies Today / Ed. ?. Valk. P. 143157.         .:  ..     .   - . ., 1998. . 712, 1761;  ..     . 17001740. ., 2000. . 7588.




159


.,  :  ..   (      ) //   . ., 1995. . 211240;  .   (   ) //  :    . ., 1995. . 110176.




160


 ..      // . .    .  . ., 1998. . 4. . 90110.




161


 ..     . . 9192.




162


.:  ..      // . 1994. 3. . 35;  .    :   ,       // . 1995. 5. . 7783;  .       XX  (  ) //  . , 1999. 1. . 819.      :  ..       :       . ., 2000. . 331342.


